Notes · No. 1

What needs to be true?

Josh Moses · November 2026 · About the footnotes

“What are you going to do differently?”

That’s the first question I’ve gotten in dozens of conversations since leaving my steady job with a mid-sized investment bank. Most founders have a banker story, and it’s rarely a good one. So why hasn’t anyone fixed it?

Because the model has worked for a long time, for the bankers.“I would, but we need the eggs.” Quarterly phone calls to “check in.” Early outreach, with or without permission, to a handful of preferred sponsors. One close relationship with a strategic who has conveniently bought three companies from the banker in question.

Then one of two things happens.

The bake-off. You decide you want to run a process. Four bankers, each of whom has already called a handful of sponsors, come clamoring to be hired without a pitch. You owe them. So you run the pitch. Everyone quotes the same fee range and the same six months to close. Each claims a special relationship with the same buyers. The senior bankers push you to pick them.“I’m your best friend. Now hire me or I’ll never speak to you again.” Eventually you settle on a name, everyone else complains, and you kick off. The senior banker shows up and asks a few questions. After that, you’re talking to the VP.Some sophisticated private equity partners know this well enough that they’ll want to speak to the VP from the beginning. No point auditioning Prince for your wedding when you know Morris Day is showing up with The Time.

The preemptive offer. One of the bankers brings you “a bona fide offer.” How can it be bona fide?Bona fide cum stercore tauri. You haven’t shared anything. “I know these guys. They stand behind their letters.” Want to learn more? You’ll have to sign the banker up on the sell-side. “They’re the buyer, but we’ll keep them honest.” It’s a little earlier than you’d hoped, but the offer is on the high end, maybe even aggressive. So you take the bait. You sign with the banker and start delivering diligence materials. The buyer disappears. “If they’re real, they’ll come back.” What happened to standing behind the letter? “Well, here’s the problem.”Your head of customer support is left-handed. The buyer didn’t know that going in. “That’s why you should have hired us earlier,” says the apologetic banker. And now you’re in a process with the banker.

Neither path is good for the founder, the investors, or the company. It’s good for the banker. So why do we do it this way?

Because it’s the way it’s done, and it’s easy. For years it produced outcomes, because the market kept going up and a handful of financial buyers were willing to pay a premium.This is identical, by the way, to buying a leveraged fund in a bull market and calling it “alpha.” But it’s not the right way.

The right way is to decide what needs to be true, and then go tell the story. That’s what we intend to do at JSM.

It starts with thinking seriously about the exit you want in 18–36 months. Maybe it’s a sponsor recap. Maybe it’s a sale to a strategic, and you’re done. Maybe you just want the highest price.This does not mean you can’t change your mind. Maybe you’d like to be nine percent body fat, but when you learn that means salmon quinoa bowls for lunch every day, you change your mind.

Then we map what it takes to get there from here. There’s no “call us when you get to $10 million in ARR.” Instead, we make sure three things are true.

You have relationships with the likely long-term strategic buyers.This means something more than “we took a meeting.” In a perfect world, you know the exact playbook you’re going to run with your partner to get to a billion-dollar exit with a specific party. And that party is terrified you’re going to run it.

That means thinking past the immediate deal, because your buyer will need a buyer of its own. Five or ten years from now, your new financial partner will have become your old financial partner. If your ideal home at that point is SAP, you need to start building the case with SAP today. That means starting the outreach, building partnership channels, getting embedded, and making the case for why SAP makes more money with you in the bag. SAP may not be the buyer in the first process.“Will not be.” But whoever is will want to know where the company goes next time around.

You are consistently hitting the metrics that get investors excited.“We are rule of forty if you ignore all the churns.” —Several companies, unfortunately.

For a pure software company, yes, that may mean the $10 million in ARR after all. It almost certainly means something like 90% gross retention, 100% net, and 80% gross margins. For a tech-enabled services business, it may mean 60% of revenue on a recurring basis, a 65% gross margin, and a 25% EBITDA margin. Getting there means building pipeline in sequence, taking care of your customers, and having upsells ready to go. It means thinking about how the blocks fit together to build the company for an exit.

You know the nightmare scenarios, and you’ve prepared for them.“Every town has an Elm Street.” —Noted geographic economist F. Krueger.

Decide early what the major objections will be. Yes, AI, TAM, the usual acronyms, but what else? Maybe you’re too concentrated with a single partner. Maybe you’re in a regulated industry. Maybe your sales are too founder-led. You want to hear these objections early, from your banker and from investors you trust, not for the first time in a management meeting. That’s how a process runs without an “uh-oh” moment.One of my very favorite deals of all time involved a company whose largest customer also happened to be a likely buyer. The contract became… very contentious.

For you as a CEO or investor, that means looking for a banker who brings expertise to the table in concentrated doses over a longer period of time. Is your banker pushing for a six-month process? Taking on seven assignments at once? Ceding the floor to the VP? Then you know what you’re getting, and it’s not what you should want.Einstein never claimed that insanity was defined by repeating the same experiment and expecting different results, but he should have. “I love misattributions.” —Abraham Lincoln.

What you should want:

  • Consistent senior attention. The person you hire should be your point of contact, not a junior banker.
  • Hands-on execution. The person you hire should be on every important call. That’s where the message gets built.
  • Equity-like commitment. Your banker should place a limited number of bets on companies they believe in, and then follow through.

This is what we’re building at JSM. It may not be the easiest way to do things. But it’s the right way.Or, if it’s not, we’re doing it anyway.

Jasper, glancing back over his shoulder

The footnotes sit in the margin on a wide screen. On a phone, tap the little numbers. Questions, objections, or a banker story of your own: start a conversation.